A Proper Pie Project or Two


Hi Reader,

Every Thanksgiving, I tell myself I'm going to make just one pie.
​
One. A perfectly respectable pumpkin pie, perhaps, with a flaky crust and a generous dollop of whipped cream. Nothing extravagant. Nothing requiring a spreadsheet or an emergency run to the supermarket.
​
Then I start looking at recipes.
​
Well, a chocolate pecan pie would be nice, wouldn't it? And surely someone will want apple. But what about pears? They're magnificent this time of year, especially tucked into a buttery almond tart.
​
Before I know it, I've planned enough desserts to feed the entire cast of The Ten Commandments. Including the extras.
​
The One has learned not to intervene.
​
The secret, after years of Thanksgiving baking, isn't making fewer pies. (Perish the thought.) It's choosing wisely and getting a head start.
​
Pie dough can be made days ahead. Many fillings come together in minutes. And some desserts actually benefit from a night in the refrigerator.
​
So with Thanksgiving just eight days away, now's the time to decide what deserves a place on your dessert table.
​
One pie? Two? Seven?
​
I'm not here to judge.

My Pie-Baking Commandments

  • Make the dough now. Most pie and tart doughs can be refrigerated for a couple of days or frozen for longer. Wrap them tightly, label them, and congratulate yourself on being the sort of organized person you've always pretended to be.
  • Keep everything cold. Cold butter, chilled dough, and a cool work surface are your allies in the pursuit of flaky pastry. If the dough starts getting sticky or the butter softens, pop it back into the refrigerator. Pastry rewards patience, not brute force.
  • Choose desserts with different personalities. A silky maple pumpkin pie, a rich chocolate pecan pie, and a bright cranberry-apple crostata make a lovely trio. You get creamy, crunchy, and fruity without serving three variations of the same dessert.
  • Don't underestimate the humble tart. Caramel pear, pear-almond, and even a simple caramel tart can look spectacular without requiring fancy decorating skills. A tart pan does half the presentation work for you. Frankly, I think it deserves a thank-you note.
  • Know what to bake ahead. Pumpkin and pecan pies generally hold well when properly refrigerated, while fruit pies and crostatas often benefit from a gentle reheating to revive their crusts. Save any last-minute whipped cream or garnishes for serving time.

Seven Thanksgiving pies and tarts are waiting below, from old-fashioned apple pie to a gloriously indulgent caramel tart.
​
Choose your favorites, clear a little freezer space, and get baking. Next Thursday will arrive whether you're ready or not.

WHAT'S INSIDE...

​Maple Pumpkin Pie​

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 4.7 from 10 votes

This maple pumpkin pie is just about as traditional as tradition can get. The crust is a flaky pâte brisée, and the filling is pumpkin purée, flavored with ginger, cinnamon, nutmeg, cloves, and the twist of maple syrup.
​☞ ​Try this recipe​

​Chocolate Pecan Pie​

This Southern chocolate pecan pie is a great classic. My American friend, the chef Art Smith, taught me how to make this, and my friends are all in love with it.
​☞ ​Try this recipe​

​Cranberry Apple Crostata​

Cranberry apple crostata is so easy to make and so unexpectedly lovely to experience it may end up displacing the more familiar dessert offerings at your Thanksgiving table.
​☞ ​Try this recipe​

​Salted Caramel Tart​

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 4.86 from 14 votes

The secret with caramel tarts, I found, is to be brave and cook the caramel until it is rich and dark without letting it burn and turn bitter. If you lack courage and don't cook it quite to the daring point that I do, the tart will still be delicious--just sweeter.
​☞ ​Try this recipe​

​Caramel Pear Tarts​

These caramel pear tarts are like individual tart tatin, made with whole pears, caramel sauce, and puff pastry.
​☞ ​Try this recipe​

​Northern Spy Apple Pie​

Northern Spy apples tend to be available later in autumn—we're talking late October or so. If you care to make this apple pie before then, go right ahead and substitute whatever baking apples you fancy.
​☞ ​Try this recipe​

​Pear Frangipane Tart​

This classic pear and almond tart, known as Tarte Bourdaloue in France, is made with pears, ground almonds, and a sweet pastry dough. Easy yet elegant.
​☞ ​Try this recipe​

Leite's Culinaria

Why, hello! Leite's Culinaria is the James Beard Award-winning site that helps home cooks and bakers put dinner on the table and laughs in the kitchen. Hungry for more? Join 40,000 food lovers and subscribe.

Read more from Leite's Culinaria

Hi Reader, There's chocolate, and then there's chocolate.You know the difference. One is a pleasant little square you eat after lunch. The other makes you close your eyes, stop talking, and seriously reconsider sharing dessert with anyone.I'm talking about the dark, rich, almost indecently good stuff.The kind of chocolate cake that leaves a smear of ganache on your fork. A mousse so silky you wonder whether chewing is even necessary. A warm tart that releases the scent of chocolate and coffee...

Yo Reader, Every November, I find myself defending pumpkin.Not from squirrels. From folk who insist it belongs only in pie, bread, and those god-awful syrupy coffee drinks that taste like someone dumped a spice rack into a cup of hot simple syrup.Now, don't get me wrong. I love pumpkin desserts. Give me a thick slice of pumpkin cake with maple cream cheese frosting, and I'll happily cancel whatever plans I had for the afternoon.But pumpkin deserves a seat at the Thanksgiving dinner table,...

Would you like a Thanksgiving Prep LIVE? Please take a moment to check out the video. Lot's of good info! Hello Reader, Are you starting to panic about Thanksgiving? Of course you're not. Because you're NORMAL. I've been freaking out for two weeks. I've created a 5-day email series. Each email tells you what to do from the Saturday to Wednesday before Thanksgiving. You can get it by clicking below. You'll automatically be added to the series. (If you can handle the holiday without medication,...