The Bird, 7 Ways, Plus the Gravy


Hi Reader,

There's a moment every Thanksgiving when an entire room falls silent.
​
It's when the turkey comes out of the oven.
​
Everyone gathers around, admiring the golden skin, inhaling the smell of roasted herbs and butter, and offering opinions nobody asked for.
​
"Looks done." "Shouldn't it rest longer?" "Are you sure it's cooked all the way through?"
​
And suddenly, the person who spent four hours roasting the damn thing is being interrogated like a suspect on Law & Order.
​
I've been that person.
​
Which is why I've learned that a successful Thanksgiving turkey has less to do with culinary heroics and more to do with choosing the right method.
​
Some years, I want the whole Norman Rockwell production: a magnificent bird, bronzed and glistening, presented on a platter. Other years, a beautifully roasted turkey breast is plenty. And when oven space is tighter than a pair of jeans after Thanksgiving dinner, I'll happily consider a pressure cooker.
​
But there's one thing I refuse to compromise on.
​
The gravy.
​
You can serve the most succulent turkey in the history of poultry, but if the gravy is thin, bland, or (God forbid) lumpy, someone's going to notice.
​
Probably me.
​
So before Thursday arrives, let's get the bird sorted out. And, for heaven's sake, the gravy.

My Turkey Rules

  • Pick the bird that fits your table. A whole roast turkey makes a glorious centerpiece, but a pancetta-and-herb-stuffed breast is terrific for smaller gatherings. Dry-brined, maple-glazed, roasted and braised, or made in the Instant Pot. There's no single righteous path to Thanksgiving dinner.
  • Give the salt time to work. Dry-brining a turkey ahead of time helps season the meat throughout and encourages beautifully browned skin. Follow your recipe's timing, and make room in the refrigerator now. Thursday morning is a little late to start negotiating with a frozen bird.
  • Trust a thermometer, not your uncle. Check the thickest part of the breast and thigh, avoiding the bone. Turkey should reach a safe internal temperature of 165°F. And remember to let the bird rest before carving so those precious juices don't end up all over your cutting board.
  • Make the gravy before the panic sets in. Prepare a good stock or gravy base ahead of time, then enrich it with the turkey drippings on Thanksgiving Day. Whisk thoroughly, taste for seasoning, and strain if necessary. A smooth, deeply flavored gravy can rescue even a slightly overenthusiastic roasting job.
  • Don't carve the minute the bird emerges. Resting gives you time to finish the sides, warm the gravy, and perhaps enjoy a glass of wine without someone shouting, "Where's the mashed potatoes?" Besides, a little patience makes carving easier.

Below are six ways to cook your Thanksgiving turkey, plus a classic gravy recipe that'll have everyone reaching for the boat.
​
Pick your bird, make a plan, and remember: Thanksgiving isn't a cooking competition.

WHAT'S INSIDE...

​Old-Fashioned Roast Turkey & Gravy​

This old-fashioned roast turkey and gravy shows why covering turkey with cheesecloth while you roast it is the perfect trick to ensuring tender meat and shatteringly crisp skin. And there's no need to stuff, truss, brine, or otherwise fuss with it.
​☞ ​Try this recipe​

​Dry Brine Turkey​

This dry brine turkey gets blanketed in a salt and sugar rub overnight and is then rinsed and roasted until golden. The result? Perfectly moist and tender turkey. No basting required.
​☞ ​Try this recipe​

​Pancetta & Herb Stuffed Turkey Breast​

Whether you're hosting a small Thanksgiving gathering, or don't have the space, time, or inclination to wrestle with a whole bird, this pancetta and herb stuffed turkey breast makes for an easy holiday main course.
​☞ ​Try this recipe​

​Maple Glazed Turkey​

This maple glazed turkey is paleo friendly and gluten free and crowd pleasing and easy to make and, as if that's not enough, magnificent in taste.
​☞ ​Try this recipe​

​Roasted & Braised Turkey​

Roasted and braised turkey makes certain that both the white and dark meat is cooked perfectly and with tons of flavor. Cooking them separately ensures that everything is succulent.
​☞ ​Try this recipe​

​Instant Pot Thanksgiving Turkey​

A 6- to 7-pound (2.75- to 3.25-kg) turkey—the perfect size for an intimate dinner party—will easily fit in your six-quart multicooker, and will produce the juiciest, most tender turkey your guests have ever had. To give the turkey a beautiful golden-brown finish, pop it under the broiler for about five minutes.
​☞ ​Try this recipe​

​Classic Turkey Gravy​

Everyone needs a classic, foolproof, go-to classic turkey gravy. This is it. And all it takes is pan juices or drippings from your turkey, stock, butter, flour, and 20 minutes of your time.
​☞ ​Try this recipe​

Leite's Culinaria

Why, hello! Leite's Culinaria is the James Beard Award-winning site that helps home cooks and bakers put dinner on the table and laughs in the kitchen. Hungry for more? Join 40,000 food lovers and subscribe.

Read more from Leite's Culinaria

Ask Me Anything About Thanksgiving LIVE Hello Reader, You said yes to my free Thanksgiving Prep Live, so here’s everything you need to join me on Zoom this Saturday, November 21, from 1 to 2 p.m. Eastern. Bring your Thanksgiving questions. We’ll tackle them together. Bring along: Your frayed nerves Your favorite drink A pen and paper All your Thanksgiving questions Your sense of fun When it’s time, click the button below. You’ll land in the waiting room, and I’ll let you in. I’ll record the...

Hi Reader, Every Thanksgiving, I tell myself I'm going to make just one pie.One. A perfectly respectable pumpkin pie, perhaps, with a flaky crust and a generous dollop of whipped cream. Nothing extravagant. Nothing requiring a spreadsheet or an emergency run to the supermarket.Then I start looking at recipes.Well, a chocolate pecan pie would be nice, wouldn't it? And surely someone will want apple. But what about pears? They're magnificent this time of year, especially tucked into a buttery...

Hi Reader, There's chocolate, and then there's chocolate.You know the difference. One is a pleasant little square you eat after lunch. The other makes you close your eyes, stop talking, and seriously reconsider sharing dessert with anyone.I'm talking about the dark, rich, almost indecently good stuff.The kind of chocolate cake that leaves a smear of ganache on your fork. A mousse so silky you wonder whether chewing is even necessary. A warm tart that releases the scent of chocolate and coffee...